2010: suggestions for Catholics with whom to build relationships during “The Year of the Catholics” / Steve St.Clair

Steve St.Clair’s suggestions for Catholics with whom to build relationships during “The Year of the Catholics”


Already-Existing Relationship Demonstrated in working together on Proposition 8:


Speech of Cardinal Francis George, O.M.I.

Archbishop of Chicago

President, U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops

Catholics and Latter-day Saints: Partners in the Defense of Religious Freedom

Brigham Young University: February 23, 2010


So I come before you today as a religious leader who shares with you a love for our own country but also, like many, with a growing concern about its moral health as a good society. In recent years, Catholics and members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints have stood more frequently side-by-side in the public square to defend human life and dignity.  In addition to working together to alleviate poverty here and abroad, we have been together in combating the degradations associated with the pornography industry; in promoting respect for the right to life of those still waiting to be born in their mother’s womb; and in defending marriage as the union of one man and one woman for the sake of family against various efforts to redefine in civil law that foundational element of God’s natural plan for creation. I am personally grateful that, after 180 years of living mostly apart from one another, Catholics and Latter-day Saints have begun to see one another as trustworthy partners in the defense of shared moral principles and in the promotion of the common good of our beloved country.


Already-Existing Relationship with “First Things”


The group of Catholics in the United States who are closest to His Excellency Pope Benedict XVI are the scholars associated with “First Things” magazine and the just-deceased Founder Richard John Neuhaus.  They are already trying to reach out to us, and my hope is that we will reciprocate in building those ties.



  • When Mitt Romney was considering running for President in early 2007 First Things published an extremely favorable article about him written by the President of the Evangelical Theological Society Francis Beckwith: When the Saint Goes Swearing in.  Dr. Beckwith very shortly after that left his Evangelical affiliation and became a Roman Catholic.




  • Three other First Things scholars also had very positive comments to the “Faith in America” Speech:  George Weigel (First Things Advisory Board), Bill Donohue (President of Catholic League), and Archbishop Charles Chaput of Denver (frequent contributor to First Things).  See it at this link:  Catholic leaders respond to Mitt Romney’s speech on Mormonism .


  • In October 2008, First Things invited a Latter-day Saint leader to be part of a dialog with an Evangelical on whether Latter-day Saints are Christian. The article by LDS First Quorum of Seventy member Bruce D. Porter and Gerald R. McDermott (the Evangelical scholar who co-wrote a book with Robert Millet).is on “First Things” at this link:  Is Mormonism Christian?


  • During the Proposition 8 debate, the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty took out a full-page advertisement in the New York Times defending the Latter-day Saints from unwarranted attacks.  See it at this link.  Looking at the names of those who signed it, we see:


  • Writer and Philosopher Roger Scruton, whose primary affiliation is First Things Magazine, to which he is a frequent contributor.


  • Rick Cizik, Chuck Colson, and Robert Seiple, who are Evangelical drafters, along with Catholic Richard John Neuhaus, of the 1994 document “Evangelicals and Catholics Together”.


  • On  the advisory board of the sponsoring “Becket Fund for Religious Liberty” along with LDS Senator Orrin Hatch, is Richard John Neuhaus of First things.



Suggested Contact: Dr Michael M. Uhlmann, E-Mail: Michael.Uhlmann@cgu.edu, Telephone:  909-621-8210

We are fortunate that there is a local Catholic scholar who is affiliated with First Things Magazine; a frequent contributor to First Things, who teaches American law and politics at Claremont Graduate University.  See a recent article by him on First Things at this link.


Replacement of Liberal Catholic Bishops by More Orthodox by Pope Benedict XVI


It is important to understand that many Catholic Bishops in the U.S. were among the first and longest to over-react to the 2nd Vatican Council. So a group of liberal leaders have been challenges to Pope Benedict XVI’s desire to bring the Catholic Church back to a “Center-Right” theological position.


See some interesting articles:

You Will Be My Witnesses: A Pastoral Letter to the People of God of San Antonio

on the Christian Mission to Evangelize and Proclaim Jesus Christ; The Most Reverend José H. Gomez, future Archbishop of Los Angeles


A young priest’s passionate calling: Jose Gomez felt the pull of the Catholic Church early on. In Los Angeles, the stern traditionalist with a genial disposition inherits an archdiocese much different from the one he led in San Antonio


A leading voice in the Catholic Church: As a bishop in Colorado and Texas, Jose Gomez did not hesitate to use his pulpit as a platform for both social justice and raw politics — causing, on occasion, considerable strife (regarding new Archbishop in Los Angeles)

Pope’s ‘revenge’ as LA gets Opus Dei bishop: A member of the radically-orthodox Catholic group Opus Dei has been appointed as the new Archbishop of Los Angeles,


Benedict’s U.S. appointments follow a pattern: center-right with a human face (National Catholic Reporter, 2009)

Aging of Catholic bishops could lead to rebirth (Originally in L.A. Times, this link is in S.J.Mercury News)

Many U.S. Catholic Bishops Set to Retire (Beliefnet)

Significant opportunity to reshape the American church: Half of California’s bishops near mandatory retirement age (California Catholic Website)

Highest-ranking Hispanic bishop in western U.S.; Jaime Soto officially takes over as leader of Sacramento diocese (California Catholic Daily)

The Catholic Bishops in Los Angeles and Orange County are considered by many as being particularly liberal (When the Swallows Come Back to Capistrano: Catholic Culture in America, First Things 2006), and have paid the cost in near-bankruptcies for sexual abuse charges.  We can certainly count on their imminent replacements being more in synch with us on abortion, gay marriage, and homosexuals in the priesthood.

As an example, see new Hispanic Bishop of Sacramento Jaime Soto, who was moved there from an assignment as Orange County’s auxiliary Bishop.  Here is a transcript of his 2008 address to the National Association of Catholic Diocesan Lesbian and Gay Ministries, “It is Sinful.” He looks and sounds like the future of Catholic leadership in southern California.

Catholic Higher Education

Much of U.S. Catholic Higher Education is also, according to people close to His Holiness, in serious trouble since the Educational Establishment declared independence from the Church Hierarchy in the 1970’s “in the spirit of the Vatican Council.”

See some interesting articles:

Catholic Culture and the Notre Dame Protests (First Things, 2009)

Who Is Catholic? New conservative colleges say existing institutions lead students away from the true faith (Chronicle of Higher Education, 2004)

Study Finds Catholic Colleges Have Little Positive Impact on Faith, Values (cardinal Newman Center)

Reflections on Pope Benedict XVI’s Address to Catholic Educators:  Truth and Freedom in the Catholic University (Cardinal Newman Center)

The Cardinal Newman Center identifies 21 Approved Colleges in the United States.

Two are in the Southern California area; and I would like to volunteer to contact  them, during our “Year of the Catholic.”

John Paul the Great Catholic University

San Diego, California

Website:  http://www.jpcatholic.com/

Suggested contact: Obviously, President Derry Connolly, being contacted by Fred Woods of BYU, is already happening.

Suggested contact: Michael Barber, Professor of Theology, Scripture and Catholic Thought, He is currently finishing a Ph.D. in Theology at Fuller in Pasadena, CA.  Blog:  http://singinginthereign.blogspot.com/ email: mpsbarber@yahoo.com

Thomas Aquinas College

Santa Paula, California

Website: http://ThomasAquinas.edu

Suggested contact: Prof. Jeffrey S. Lehman, M.A. Biola University, Adjunct Instructor of Philosophy and Theology, Biola University; e-mail: jlehman@thomasaquinas.edu

What About Notre Dame? People who want their students to keep a love and appreciation of the Catholic Church and a belief in its teachings and willingness to follow its practices should probably send them somewhere else.



BYU Religion Department Professor with Ph.d. from Notre Dame University

Suggested Contact: Dr. Alonzo L. Gaskill is an Assistant Professor of Church History and Doctrine. He grew up as a member of the Eastern Orthodox Church. He holds a Bachelors degree in Philosophy, a Masters in Theology, and a Ph.D. from Notre Dame in Biblical Studies.

Brother Gaskill’s books include Know Your Religions Vol. 1 – Mormonism & Catholicism

Brother Gaskill would be a perfect LDS Representative to Catholic scholars and Catholic leaders, or LDS Firesides and Public Affairs presentations.

E-Mail: Alonzo_gaskill@byu.edu


Leave a comment

Filed under LDS Conservative Christian Dialog, LDS Focusing on Jesus Christ

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s